Breaking Down the Path to Ethical AI in Healthcare

AI has so much potential to improve healthcare - from helping doctors diagnose to enabling precision care for patients which couldn’t have been possible earlier. But AI can also go wrong if ethics aren't made a priority from the start.

Advaith from MarianaAI
Product
February 15, 2024

In 2019, Science reported that an algorithm used to predict health care needs for more than 100 million people was biased against Black patients. Imagine you're a patient relying on an AI diagnostic tool, only to learn it's twice as likely to misdiagnose your condition compared to other groups. Or a hospital using your private health data to train algorithms without your consent. Failures like these shatter public trust.

Recent surveys reveal widespread concern among the public regarding the ethics of healthcare AI. One poll found 78% of patients worried about privacy violations, while another showed only 13% of healthcare organizations have fully developed AI ethics frameworks. So how do we make sure AI in healthcare is ethical? There are a few core principles to focus on:

Exploring the Core of Healthcare AI Ethics

Transparency: AI Medical Scribes need to be transparent, and at the same time, explainable - they should be able to explain how they make recommendations. This helps build trust and ensures someone takes responsibility for AI-assisted choices.

Fairness in AI calls for equality in treatment and outcomes. Take the case of an AI system used for diagnosing skin conditions. If trained only on data from lighter-skinned individuals, it may underperform with darker skin, leading to misdiagnoses. Ensuring fairness means checking these systems for biases and ensuring they perform equally well across diverse populations.

And of course, AI systems must be safe and reliable. If an AI tool is diagnosing heart disease, it's not enough for it to be accurate most of the time. People's lives are on the line, so it needs to work reliably every time. Extensive testing is a must.

Privacy and Data Security: Protecting patient privacy is crucial too. Strict rules are needed on how patient data can be used, in line with privacy laws. This includes ethically sourcing AI training data with proper consent and robust cybersecurity to prevent data breaches.

There are still big ethical hurdles to overcome while using AI for healthcare:

AI can inherit human biases around race, gender, and more that lead to unfair treatment. Regular checks are key to finding and fixing these biases. Patient privacy is also at serious risk with all the sensitive health data involved. Strong measures must be in place to prevent unauthorized access.

And, sometimes there's a trade-off between explainability and accuracy in AI systems. But in healthcare, understanding how AI makes decisions is too important - both are needed. With AI taking over roles like documentation, who's ultimately responsible when things go wrong? Clear rules are needed to assign liability.

Building Ethical AI for Healthcare

So where does this leave us? Creating truly ethical AI for healthcare takes work:

From the outset, AI design should be guided by ethical principles. Cross-disciplinary teams, including ethicists, can provide a holistic view of the potential impacts. Ethical sourcing of data, with informed consent and unbiased datasets, is foundational. Knowing where and how data is sourced (data provenance) is key to maintaining accountability.

Five Ethical Challenges in Healthcare | AMN Healthcare

Ongoing testing for biases and errors is required, especially for generative AI, which is expected to see significant adoption in 2024. Finally, defining clear processes for responsibility, including human oversight, is essential. This helps in delineating the roles of developers, providers, and users in AI applications. And engaging with patients, doctors, and other stakeholders ensures AI tools are relevant and improved based on real-world feedback.

The path ahead isn't easy, but it's necessary. By making ethics a priority today, we can unlock AI's huge potential in healthcare tomorrow - in a way that's innovative, inclusive, and deserving of trust.

What if AI could Bridge Ethical Gaps in Healthcare??

In the healthcare sector, AI integration into traditionally low-impact tasks illustrates a scenario where it's less about the risk of going wrong and more about degrees of improvement. From handling patient data to assisting in preliminary diagnostics, AI is proving its worth by enhancing efficiency and accuracy. These improvements, though incremental, are pivotal in healthcare, where small advancements can lead to significant benefits in operational efficiency and patient care.

With President Biden's focus on regulatory responsibility in AI, the future of healthcare AI is poised for transformative change. The emphasis on ethical standards, transparency, and human oversight is reshaping the landscape. Health systems are gearing up for this change, with many like Providence and Cleveland Clinic planning to adopt generative AI to reduce burdens on clinicians and improve patient interactions.

Through collaboration and a focus on equity, transparency, and accountability, AI can profoundly and positively transform healthcare, paving the way for a future where technology enhances human well-being without compromising ethical standards.

In this evolving landscape, AI should be valued not for its infallibility, but for its capacity to continually enhance and refine crucial aspects of healthcare delivery.